Paper Moon is the New Blu-ray Pick of the Week

paper moon criterion collection blu-ray

This is the week of Thanksgiving. At least in the United States it is. Though I suspect that has started to take hold in other countries as well. At least the pre-Christmas sales aspect anyway. Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving, was traditionally the biggest sales day for American retailers. But the Internet ruined that. Why do we need to go to the store at some un-godly hour Friday morning to get the sales, when you can just shop at home in your pajamas?

First, there was Cyber Monday, then Small Business Saturday. Then the big box stores started opening up on Thanksgiving Day for their sales, now it seems like everyone starts running sales the day after Halloween and they don’t stop until Christmas Day.

I’ve been writing a Pick of the Week column for many years now. Traditionally this week saw a huge collection of new releases, boxed sets, and special editions. Then every week until Christmas week there would be more.

This week seems pretty tame for some reason. Last week saw some good releases, and I’m sure there will be even more in the coming weeks, but that bonanza we usually see this week seems to be missing.

Oh, lots of stuff is coming out, mostly 4K UHD editions of films you probably already own on Blu-ray. I suppose I should be excited about those, but I’m not. They won’t even get a mention. Someday I might be excited about those bumps in video quality, but today is not that day.

Instead, my pick this week is an old Peter Bogdanovich film getting a 4K release from Criterion. Which, come to think of it, I guess I’ve just contradicted myself because here I am getting excited about a UHD release of a film that has already had a Blu-ray release.

I contain multitudes.

I’ve not actually seen Paper Moon before, but I recently watched Bogdanovich’s debut film, Targets, and quite liked it and when he died everyone talked about Paper Moon so here we are.

The film is set during The Great Depression and stars Ryan O’Neal as a man who gets saddled with Tatum O’Neal (who is Ryan’s real-life daughter and may or may not be his character’s daughter in this film) with whom he forges a unique bond. Criterion is filling it with their usual extras and care.

The Shape of Water: Criterion Collection is also giving Guillermo del Toro’s unusual love story between a woman and a fish-man the 4K UHD treatment.

That’s Entertainment: To celebrate their 50th anniversary in 1974 MGM created this clip-reel compilation of many of their best musicals. Then they got many of the stars of those films to introduce the clips. I can remember watching this as a kid on television and I guess it started my love of musicals. This release has cleaned up a lot of those old clips so it should look better than ever.

Noirvember: Targets (1968)

targets poster

In August of 1966 Charles Whitman, after stabbing his wife and mother to death, climbed a clock tower at the University of Texas at Austin and shot over 30 people with a rifle.

Two years later Peter Bogdanovich directed his first movie. Famed producer Roger Corman told Bogdanovich he could make any movie he liked under two conditions. First Boris Karloff owed him two days worth of work so the film would have to utilize that. Second, he had to use clips from Corman’s own film with Karloff, The Terror (1963). Other than that he could do what he wanted (within the budget constraints of course.)

Targets blends a slightly autobiographical tale of Karloff as an aging horror actor who finds real life’s horrors to be more than he can take, and a Charles Whitman-esque “average man” who goes on a shooting spree. The way that these two separate stories merge is quite fascinating.

Karloff is Byron Orlok an elderly actor who starred in the type of horror movies Karloff used to star in. But he finds he no longer has an audience. Those old films seem dated and cheesy to modern audiences. Real life with its relentless real violence is much scarier than those old movies. He announces he’s going to retire, much to the chagrin of Sammy Michaels (Peter Bogdanovich) a director who has just written a part specifically for Orlok.

During these scenes, we watch Orlok watch scenes from The Terror, and later we’ll see him watch himself in The Criminal Code (1933). It is quite a treat to watch Karloff watching himself on screen.

Orlok is unrelenting in his decision to retire but does agree to make an appearance at a drive-in theater where one of his films will be shown.

Meanwhile, Bobby Thompson (Tim O’Kelly) is a seemingly normal young man. He has a pretty wife and a perfectly average set of parents with whom they live in a nice little house. He likes to go hunting with his father. He likes guns.

The film gives us hints that not all is well with the Thompsons. Nothing dramatic, but his interactions with his wife are bland. His conversations with his parents are empty. We watch them sit around the television laughing blankly at some broad comedy.

Then he kills his wife and mother, loads up a bag full of weapons, sits atop an oil storage tank, and begins taking potshots at cars on a nearby highway. When the cops arrive he escapes, making his way to a drive-thru playing some old film starring Byron Orlok.

Bogdanovich shoots all of this with a low-key style. He wisely doesn’t make any overt statements about movies and violence, allowing the viewer to draw their own conclusions.

It is a fascinating film and one that amazes me that it ever got made. There aren’t a lot of people who could take that mandate from Roger Corman and make something at all watchable, that Bogdanovich turned it into something great is a minor miracle.