I’m sometimes a little loose with my definition of “horror” in these posts. I suppose when most people think of horror, they think of monsters – vampires, werewolves, ghosts, and the like. And obviously horror is that, but don’t forget about the knife-wielding maniacs. It is those that we’re going to dive into a little bit here.
Gialli and slashers all employ knife-wielding maniacs to great effect. No one would argue that those aren’t horror films. But some of those, Gialli especially, involve a mystery element. Someone is killing people, and someone else – a detective, reporter, or some citizen tries to find out who the culprit is. There is a mystery, and our heroes try to solve it.
Murder mysteries and thrillers often have similar elements. So what differentiates one of those from a horror? You could argue that horror tends to up the violence and gore, but I’ve seen plenty of blood-soaked thrillers. They are often just as good at creating tension and suspense. Horror does tend to have more jump scares, but that can’t be it because loads of horror movies don’t have jump scares at all.
In the end, genre is flexible. Movies can be more than one thing.
I don’t think anyone would really call A Kiss Before Dying a horror film, but it is a neo-noir. Lots of neo-noirs have horror elements. Because it is Noirvember, I wanted to watch a horror-tinged noir, and I went looking for a neo-noir, as they tend to lean into those elements a little more, and I landed on this. Though there is some murder in this and a little bit of gore, it really doesn’t check the horror boxes.
But I’ve not talked about my film noir movies this month as much as I’d like to, so we are just going to roll with it.
Jonathan Corliss (Matt Dillon) was born into a poor family living in an old house right next to a busy railroad line. Every day, as a boy, he’d sit in his bedroom watching the trains go by. Usually, they’d have a name stamped on them – Carlsson Copper. That name meant money and glory to him.
Years pass, and all he wants to do is find some of that fortune for himself. Carlsson Copper is run by Thor Carlsson (Max von Sydow). He has twin daughters – Ellen and Dorothy (Sean Young). Jonathan meets Dorothy at Yale and seduces her. They fall in love and hope to get married.
But Thor is a jealous, tyrannical father. He doesn’t approve of Dorothy’s boyfriends. For the previous one, he had a private detective follow them around. Because of this, Dorothy and Jonathan have been sneaking around, not letting anyone know they are together. Then she gets pregnant. She knows Thor will disown her for that. She won’t inherit any of his money. Dorothy doesn’t care; she’s in love. Jonathan kills her for it, making it look like a suicide.
Ellen doesn’t believe her sister would commit suicide, and she does her own investigation. Somewhere along the line, she, too, is seduced by Jonathan, and they get married. She, of course, has no idea Jonathan was Dorothy’s mystery boyfriend.
Before they get married, Ellen gets some information from a previous boyfriend of Dorothy. He thinks he knows who the mystery man is. But before he can tell her, Jonathan kills him, again making it look like suicide and making him look like Dorothy’s killer. There will be more murders before the credits roll. But none of them are particularly tense or scary.
For a time, Ellen believes her sister’s murder is solved. But when those other deaths occur, she begins to doubt. She starts to investigate again. Meanwhile. Jonathan has made friends with Thor and even become his assistant. He’s enjoying his life of luxury, and Ellen is starting to cause trouble in that regard. You can probably figure out how it turns out.
It has been a while since I watched Sean Young in a movie. I forgot how much I enjoy her. Matt Dillon was born for this sort of role. There’s nothing really new to see in this film. It feels like a perfectly average early 1990s neo-noir. It is worth watching, but ask me about it next week, and I’ll likely struggle to tell you anything about it.

