Paul Simon/Bob Dylan
Jones Beach Ampitheatre
Wantagh NY
7-30-99
Tracks:
Paul Simon:
Bridge Over Troubled Water
Can’t Run But
The Boy In The Bubble
The Coast
Trailway Bus
Mrs. Robinson
Me And Julio Down By The Schoolyard
Further To Fly
Graceland
The Cool, Cool River
Slip Sliding Away
Diamonds On The Soles Of Her Shoes
You Can Call Me Al
Late In The Evening
Still Crazy After All These Years
Dylan/Simon duets:
The Sound Of Silence
I Walk The Line/The Wanderer
Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door
Bob Dylan:
Babe, It Ain’t No Lie
Mr. Tambourine Man
Desolation Row
Girl Of The North Country
Tangled Up In Blue
All Along The Watchtower
Shelter From The Storm
Maggie’s Farm
Not Dark Yet
Highway 61 Revisited
Encore
Like A Rolling Stone
It Ain’t Me, Babe
Not Fade Away
My review:
In the summer of 1999, Bob Dylan and Paul Simon embarked on a four-month-long, 38-date tour together as co-headliners (they would switch back and forth in terms of who was the opening act).
This night in Wantagh is the penultimate night of the first leg of the tour. After the next night’s show in Wantagh, they took a few weeks off and came back together in Florida on September 2.
Some kind soul recorded the SBD feed beamed out to the stadium on an FM channel to help those with hearing difficulties. Rattlesnake Records bootlegged that recording on a disc they called Something Is Happening On Mr. Jones’ Beach. Lossless Bob indicates at least one other bootleg of the show, but as far as I can tell, it comes from this same recording (probably just a copy of the Rattlesnake bootleg). A taper named Doinker also recorded the show. And then someone calling themselves OctopusRider did a matrix mix of the SBD and the Doinker recording, but only for the Dylan set.
I listened to the SBD. It is missing “Babe, It Ain’t No Lie.”
The SBD is marred by some volume fluctuations, and it sounds very flat. At least to my (admittedly not great ears.) I listened to the first several songs in my car on the way to work. I immediately didn’t like the sound. It sounded not only flat, but cold and distant. I tried it on my cheap earphones, and it sounded worse.
That afternoon I took my daughter somewhere and put on some Big Thief for her listening pleasure. She immediately complained about the sound quality. We played around with the car’s settings and realized that something was off. The back speakers weren’t working at all, and there was no equalizer adjustments for the front speakers.
No wonder this recording sounded so terrible. The radio worked fine, but when I connected my phone up, something screwed up. It took me a couple of days to fix it. But what an improvement once I did. Now, as I mentioned, the sound still isn’t pristine. It still sounds a bit cold, and there are those annoying fluctuations. But it is highly listenable. I just did a quick test listen to the matrix, and it sounds terrific. You just don’t get the Simon performance.
I have a few Paul Simon concert recordings. The ones from the 1980s onward are all performed with a big band, creating what I call the Graceland sound. The shows are filled with lots of percussion and horns, and a large vocal section.
The opening track this night, “Bridge Over Troubled Water,” has none of that. It sounds more like something Daniel Lanois would produce. It is haunting and atmospheric. Simon can no longer hit those high notes, but he still does a nice job with it.
“Can’t Run, But” gets a little more robust, but not much. But by the time he hits the third song, “The Boy in the Bubble,” things get really good. There are big horns, big guitars, and big backup vocals. Graceland is one of my favorite albums, and this song is one of my favorites from that album, and this version is wonderful.
When I was a teenager, first discovering Paul Simon (or Simon & Garfunkel, rather), I absolutely hated “Mrs. Robinson.” The reasons were mostly stupid (but would probably make for a good My Life In Music post; look for that soon). I always skipped it when playing the record, or when it came on the radio. I’ve since gotten over those stupid reasons, but I still don’t really care for the song. It has some clever lyrics, but it’s never really done anything for me. This is a perfectly fine version.
“Me and Julio” is always fun, and this is an energetic performance. “Cool Cool River” is great, and it concludes with this wonderful cacophony of horns. He doesn’t have Ladysmith Black Mambazo with him (if you ever get to see them live, I highly recommend it; they are awesome), so the opening to “Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes” is toned down quite a bit. They do try a bit of acapella singing, but it doesn’t work very well. Once they get into the tune, though, it turns out well.
“You Can Call Me Al” and “Late in the Evening” are super fun with lots of great horn work.
Dylan comes out to duet with Paul on three songs. They sing together on “The Sound of Silence,” which is interesting. Simon has a traditionally good voice; it is very pretty, whereas Dylan has…well, he has Dylan’s voice. I love it, but he’s never been known as a technically great singer. It is full of grit and gravel. Put them together, and it’s not exactly a beautiful harmony, but it works. Next, they do a medley of “I Walk The Line/The Wanderer,” and it is clear they are both having so much fun.
But it is “Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door” that’s the showstopper. I believe it is Simon’s band still on the stage, and the addition of horns makes this rendition something special. They turn it into a reggae number, and it is just amazing. Bob and Paul trade off verses, with them both singing the chorus. Again, it is clear they are having a great time. Toward the end, they launch into a chorus of “I hear ya knockin’, but you can’t come in,” and I just love it.
Bob in 1999-2000 is some of my favorite Dylan ever. Larry Campbell and Charlie Sexton on guitars is where it is at. But the whole band really gels perfectly well. For my money, Paul Simon was the warm-up, and this is the show.
I’ve always loved how, during this period, Dylan always opened with an old traditional number. It really sets the stage. “Oh, Babe It Ain’t No Lie” fits that bill. Then we get into it with “Mr. Tambourine Man,” which finds everyone in fine form. There is a nice bit of duelling guitars at the close. Next comes “Desolation Row,” and it is fantastic. Great acoustic guitar playing. Bob’s vocal is so tender and pure on “Girl From the North Country.”
During this period, “Tangled Up In Blue” often had an extended acoustic jam that I usually just love. It feels a little off-balance here, but is still quite good. Larry Campbell sits at the pedal steel guitar for “Shelter From the Storm,” and it is amazing.
“Not Dark Yet” is one of my favorite late-period Bob Dylan tunes, and this version is fantastic. Long ago, I created a playlist for some of my favorite live versions of songs, and this went immediately into it.
“Highway 61” puts Larry back on pedal steel. There is some very fine electric guitar work.
The encore begins with “Like a Rolling Stone.” It is very good. Then we get treated to a ten-minute version of “It Ain’t Me, Babe” featuring some terrific acoustic guitar jamming. Then we close it out with a raucous “Not Fade Away.”
Great show overall. This is definitely not Paul Simon’s best performance. I’ve heard him do much better. It doesn’t help that the soundboard recording fluctuates so much. But it’s still good stuff. But it’s the Dylan set that makes this a must-have. That and the duets.
Bob Links has another review of the concert.
Lossless Bob has six LB#s for this show; you can find them here.
I have three sources. You can see text files and artwork here.
YouTube has a video of the show, recorded from the audience.