Joe Sullivan (Dennis O’Keefe) has been sitting in prison for a few years. He took the fall for a big robbery. His legal caseworker, Ann Martin (Marsha Hunt), thinks she can get him out on parole in a year or three. She visits him a lot. She thinks he’s basically a good guy. She’s fallen in love with him.
Meanwhile, his girl, Pat Regan (Claire Trevor) has a plan to bust him out. Mobster Rick Coyle (Raymond Burr), who was Joe’s accomplice in the crime that put him in prison, has greased some wheels, which will open some prison doors. In truth, it was Coyle who set it up so that Joe would take the fall, and he fully expects Joe to get killed trying to escape.
He’ll have no such luck. Joe does escape with the help of Pat and her getaway car. Their luck isn’t that great either, as the guards shoot a hole in their gas tank. Needing a place to hole up, Joe takes them to Ann’s apartment. At first, she begs Joe to turn himself in. At first, he says he’ll let her go as soon as the heat’s down. But he keeps making her go with them. She starts to remember why she liked him in the first place.
In the middle is Pat. Claire Trevor plays her tough as nails. She knows the score. She knows who Joe really is. She urges him to do what he needs to do to get lost, to leave the country and never come back. But Ann is part of his better angels. She urges him to do the right thing no matter the circumstances.
Meanwhile, Coyle keeps setting Joe up. Coyle has the money he owes Joe from that robbery, and he says he’ll meet him somewhere and give it to him. But in reality, he sends a couple of his goons to wait and kill Joe.
Pat keeps telling him he doesn’t need the money. He doesn’t need revenge. They just need to get on the boat and get out of there. Ann keeps telling him to turn himself in. But Joe wants that money. He wants his revenge.
Director Anthony Mann keeps things moving at a steady pace. I mostly know him as a director of westerns, but darn if he doesn’t know how to handle a noir. Cinematographer John Alton nails the noir shadows and light perfectly.
I know O’Keefe mostly from light comedies, but he’s good here. He makes Joe a tough guy with a sensitive side. Hunt is good too. Ann has to be a blend of smart, caring, a good girl, and someone who’d fall for a guy like Joe. Even when he does a lot of bad things. But the film belongs to Trevor. She’s a firecracker.
I love Noirvember. I love discovering these little gems. Seek this one out.