Season one of The Terror is one of my favorite seasons of television over the last decade. It is a beautiful piece of historical fiction about a group of 19th-century British sailors trying to find a Northwest Passage and discovering something sinister in the frozen wasteland. I don’t think it was originally intended as an anthology series, but it became one. I have not seen the second season set in a Japanese internment camp during World War II, but they say it is very good.

And now, some seven years later, we are getting Season 3. I didn’t actually know this was part of The Terror until I started watching it. On their main screens, AMC+ just shows it as The Devil in Silver. But the opening credits do say The Terror. I don’t know why. Had I known, I would have watched Season 2 first.

The Devil in Silver follows Pepper (Dan Stevens), a guy who had the great misfortune of getting into a fight with his girlfriend’s ex, with the police nearby who were at the end of their shift. Rather than arrest him and deal with the paperwork, they take him to a mental hospital where he’s put on a 72-hour hold. If he behaves, they say, he’ll be released. As is the way with these things, he gets stuck there indefinitely.

New Hyde Hospital is a rundown, shabby place, and the series hits the state of our mental healthcare with a hammer. Hospitals are underfunded, understaffed, and tend to treat the symptoms with drugs rather than get to the heart of the actual disease. Also, there may be a monster. It might also be a scary patient they keep locked behind a silver door. But probably it is a monster since this series is all about the supernatural.

Our first two episodes introduced the situation and our characters: patients and doctors. It is a great cast, with Aasif Mandvi as the head administrator, CCH Pounder as one of the doctors, Stephen Root as the book club leader, and Judith freaking Light as one of the patients (I haven’t seen her in anything since Who’s the Boss, but one look at her IMDB page shows she’s kept busy – good for her.)

Pepper is angry and belligerent. He’s the McMurphy in One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest in this scenario. Episode Three begins with the aftermath of Episode Two, where he was attacked by the monster. He awakes to find that the doctors are telling the story that he became belligerent and violent, and they had to get rough with him – hence his injuries.

He tries asking the patients who this patient is behind the silver door, but they give conflicting answers when they give answers at all. When he’s told that the patients are going to be taken to a pizza parlor for a treat in a few days, he decides that’s where he’ll make his escape. To keep the patients calm (and zoinked out of their minds), the staff gives everybody some heavy downers. Pepper doesn’t swallow it and tells his roommate his plan. The roommate tells someone else, and before you know it, all the patients are not taking their meds. The pizza party is a disaster with everyone acting, well, crazy, and Pepper ultimately decides he needs to stay to try to help them get real help.

He is once again confronted by the monster, who basically tells him if he doesn’t comply, he’ll kill everybody.

Ok, I’m once again rambling for too long. I really don’t want to do full recaps. I just don’t have the patience for it, but I’m struggling talking about single episodes without giving out quite a bit of information.

I’m struggling with this show. It has a great cast, and the story has potential. Though it does lean a little too heavily into the well-worn tropes of mental institutions. It’s lacking something. Maybe a specificity to the characters. The actors, especially Judith Light, give it their all, but I don’t find myself interested in them. And they’ve brought out the monster too soon. It’s not really that scary but keeps lurking about and doing stuff. I’d prefer a bigger mystery about what it is and what it wants.

The cast is good enough that I’m going to keep watching, but I truly hope it gets better.